Allow 24 hours for processing, plus carrier transit. UPS 2nd Day Air and UPS Next Day Air transit times begin after processing and carrier handoff. Weekend orders begin processing the next business day.
Check available shipping options at checkout; processing time is additional to transit. Christmas arrival is not assured unless a verified option below applies to your order.
Add four pieces using the flavor carousel below. Pick four favorites or add the same flavor four times. Your cart tracks your progress and Shopify applies the discount automatically.
Four pieces. Your favorite flavors.
Choose your fudge flavors
Buy 3 pieces, choose the 4th free
Buy 3, get the 4th free0 of 4 pieces
1234
Choose 3 pieces to unlock your free fourth.
Swipe to explore
Chocolate Fudge
$11.99
Rich, creamy chocolate fudge made from our classic chocolate batch for a timeless melt-in-your-mouth treat.
Chocolate Walnut Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge packed with English walnuts and topped with more walnuts for a classic combination.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge blended with creamy peanut butter and layered with a peanut butter ribbon in every bite.
Dark Sea Salt Caramel Fudge
$11.99
Dark chocolate fudge with sea salt, a ribbon of salted caramel, and a final sprinkle of sea salt in every bite.
Turtle Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge packed with pecans, layered with caramel, and topped with more caramel and pecans.
Peanut Butter Fudge
$11.99
Creamy white fudge blended with plenty of smooth peanut butter for a rich, melt-in-your-mouth bite in every bite.
Peanut Butter Cup Fudge
$11.99
Creamy peanut butter fudge packed with peanut butter cups and chocolate chips throughout each loaf in every bite.
Butter Pecan Fudge
$11.99
Creamy white fudge cooked with butter, flavored with butter pecan, and packed with crunchy pecans in every bite.
Cookies n Cream Fudge
$11.99
Creamy vanilla fudge packed with crushed Oreo cookies and topped with even more Oreo pieces in every bite.
Maple Fudge
$11.99
Rich maple fudge with deep brown sugar flavor and a delicate brown sugar finish on top of each loaf.
Chocolate Raspberry Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge infused with raspberry and topped with bright freeze-dried raspberries in every bite.
German Chocolate Fudge
$11.99
Dark chocolate fudge flavored with coconut, packed with walnuts, and topped with toasted coconut in every bite.
Dark Chocolate Fudge
$11.99
Extra-rich dark chocolate fudge made with additional cocoa and finished with chocolate chips on top.
Salted Caramel Cashew Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge with sea salt, roasted cashews, and a ribbon of salted caramel through the center.
Rocky Road Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge packed with sliced almonds and soft mini marshmallows for a classic rocky road bite.
Maple Nut Fudge
$11.99
Rich maple fudge packed with crunchy walnuts and finished with a delicate brown sugar topping in every bite.
Vanilla Fudge
$11.99
Creamy white fudge flavored with pure vanilla for a smooth, rich, and timeless confectionery classic.
Mint Chocolate Chip Fudge
$11.99
Creamy mint fudge loaded with chocolate chips throughout and finished with even more chips on top in every bite.
Eastern Black Walnut Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge packed with distinctive black walnuts for a bold, earthy, and deeply nutty bite.
Black Forest Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge flavored with amaretto and packed with dried cherries and walnuts throughout in every bite.
Birthday Cake Fudge
$11.99
Rich chocolate fudge flavored with cake batter and packed with colorful sprinkles throughout and on top.
Christmas Cookie Fudge
$11.99
Creamy cake batter fudge packed with cupcake pieces and sprinkles, then topped with Christmas sprinkles.
Cherry Fudge
$11.99
Creamy cherry fudge packed with dried cherries and walnuts for a fruity, nutty bite in every piece in every bite.
Hot Cocoa Fudge
$11.99
Creamy cocoa fudge packed with marshmallows, then topped with toasted marshmallows and candy cane pieces.
Mint Meltaway Fudge
$11.99
Dark chocolate fudge flavored with crème de menthe and packed with crushed Andes mint pieces in every bite.
Vanilla Nut Fudge
$11.99
Creamy vanilla fudge packed with crunchy pecans for a smooth, buttery, and classic nutty combination.
Snickerdoodle Fudge
$11.99
Creamy cinnamon-vanilla fudge layered and topped with cinnamon sugar for a buttery snickerdoodle bite.
Vegan Chocolate Fudge
$12.99
Rich vegan chocolate fudge made with oat milk for a smooth, creamy, dairy-free chocolate experience.
Sugar Free Chocolate Plain Fudge
$13.99
We took the original version of our "Emmy Award" fudge and tried to give it our best Sugar Free makeover! We think th...
Pumpkin Pie Fudge
$11.99
Creamy white fudge cooked with pumpkin pie filling, butter, pumpkin spice, and a touch of clove in every bite.
Vegan Peanut Butter Fudge
$12.99
Creamy vegan peanut butter fudge made with oat milk and plenty of peanut butter mixed throughout in every bite.
Sugar Free Peanut Butter Fudge
$13.99
To all the Sugar Free Peanut Butter lovers who need a fix, look no longer! Our Sugar Free Peanut Butter will make you...
Vegan Chocolate Almond Fudge
$12.99
Rich vegan chocolate fudge made with oat milk, almond flavor, and sliced almonds mixed throughout in every bite.
Penuche Fudge
$11.99
Old-fashioned brown sugar penuche fudge with a maple-style base and a caramelized brown sugar topping.
Vegan Christmas Cookie Fudge
$12.99
Creamy oat milk cake batter fudge mixed with sprinkles and topped with festive Christmas sprinkles in every bite.
Made to share
A sweet thought for everyone on your list.
Pick favorites for family and friends, bring something sweet for your host, or share a few slices with coworkers.
Our fudge is cooked in copper kettles and finished by hand on marble slabs. Bring a little of Frankenmuth home.
Keep fudge wrapped in its original wax paper at room temperature.
A few sweet details
How does the fourth free slice work?
Add four actual slices from the carousel, including the fourth. Shopify applies the eligible buy-three-get-one-free discount in the cart. Vegan and Sugar Free slices may cost more. Prebuilt assortments are separate products and excluded from this slice offer.
What about ingredients and allergens?
Review the individual flavor product pages before choosing. Contact us about allergies or ingredient questions before ordering.
How should I store my gift?
Keep fudge wrapped at room temperature and enjoy within two to three weeks. Do not refrigerate. See our storage and freezing guide.
Will my order arrive for Christmas?
You can plan for fresh holiday fudge by choosing an available holiday shipping week with Ship It Later in your cart. We ship during the week you select. Choose this option before checkout; orders are not delayed automatically. A shipping week is not a guaranteed delivery date.
Available services depend on your basket and destination. Processing adds time before carrier transit; weekends and holidays can affect delivery. Select the correct service at checkout and review the shipping policy. Contact us before ordering if timing is essential.
